810 < Super-Cassettes-v Q S-OS-16 IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI CSCOMM 1802019 SUPER CASSETTES PRIVATE LIMITED Plaintiff Through MrAmit Sibal Sr Adv with MrHarsh Kaushik mr Abhay Chattopadhyaya and MrVarun Tandon Advs versus FELIX ARVID ULF KJELLBERG&ORS Through CORAM HON'BLE MR JUSTICE JAYANT NATH ORDER 08042019 Allowed subject to all just exceptions Let the plaint be registered as suit Issue summons to the defendants through ordinary process and speed post returmable for 15072019 This application is filed under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC seeking ad interim injunction in favour of the plaintiff and against defendants No 1 to 3 from uploading communicating or making available the impugned songs namely T-Series Diss TrackBitch Lasagna and Congratulations or any other version thereof High Court of Delhi New Delhi Bar and Bench wwwbarandbenchcom 2 The accompanying suit is filed seeking a decree of permanent injunction in favour of the plaintiff and against defendants No 1 to 3 from uploading communicating exploiting etc the impugned songs as noted above Other connected reliefs are also sought 3 I is submitted in the accompanying plaint that defendant No 1 operates a YouTube Channel namely PewDiePie and has for quite some time been the most subscribed channel on YouTube in the world Of late the popularity of the Plaintiff has increased so significantly in the world market that the plaintiff has recently overtaken defendant No 1 as the most subscribed YouTube Channel in the world across all categories It is pleaded that in a bid to outscore the Plaintiff and regain its top position Defendant No has been uploading defamatory and disparaging music videos which target the plaintiff and Indians as a racist inflammatory and hateful remarks against them as well as T-Series in a bid to ridicule and disparage the plaintiff and its trademarks It is pleaded that the lyrics used in the two impugned songs uploaded by Defendant No 1 in conjunction with the other defendants No 2 and 3 are on the face of it defamatory disparaging nsulting and offensive These videos are accessible throughout the world to a global audience of more than a billion who access internet and YouTube every day 4 Defendants No 4 to 6 have a platform ie YouTube where the said videos have been uploaded by defendants No 1 to 3 Hence they have been impleaded as a party A perusal of the snapshots of the videos which have been uploaded by defendants No 1 to 3 shows that there are repeated comments made which are abusive vulgar and also racist in nature In my opinion it would be in community and contains High Court of Dalh New Delh Bar and Bench wwwbarandbenchcom the interest of justice that these videos are taken off by defendants No 4 to 6 6 It may be noted that vide communication dated 07102018 defendant No 1 apologized for the posting stating that it was all in good fun He had also assured that he is not planning any more videos on the same line 7 However leaned senior counsel for the plaintiff points out that recently on 31032019 a new video has been uploaded by defendants No 1 to 3 which are on the same line as the earlier videos 8 The plaintiff has made out a prima facie case Balance of convenience is also in favour of the plaintiff Defendants No 4 to 6 are directed to remove and disable access to the impugned videos of the song namely T Series Diss TrackBitch Lasagna presently available at httpswwwyoutubecom watch?v-6Dh RL uN4&list-RD6Dh RL uN4&start_radio-l and song namely Congratulations presently available https wwwyoutubecom watch?v-PHge8Q6qTj c&t-36s and also ensure that the said videos do not get uploaded ever again on the platform wwwyoutubecom 9 Issue notice post returnable for 15072019 10 The plaintiff to comply with Order 39 Rule 3 CPC within two weeks from today to the defendants through ordinary process and speed A copy of this order be given dasti under the signatures of the Court Master JAYANT NATHJ APRIL 08 2019 rb Coulhl Yeah sure Meme

Bitch

community

Diss

Internet

Music

Party

Radio

Taken

Target

videos

yeah

youtube.com

Access

Congratulations

Connected

Ensure

Good

Justice

Lasagna

Limited

Lyrics

Nature

Quite

Songs

Time

Today

Video

Watch

World

youtube.com

Racist

Harsh

April

Music Videos

Ridicule

Been

super

fun

song

private

com

speed

who

list

indians

top

delhi

case

bar

platform

new delhi

may

etc

versus

communication

market

day

billion

channel

them

all

face

the world

master

they

new

application

court

comments

series

the face

post

categories

balance

made

order

youtube channel

for

www

t series

felix

cpc

trademarks

issue

injunction

every day

used

conjunction

senior

more

pewdiepie

this

two weeks

get

high

sure

making

yeah sure

well

bench

suit

just

thereof

as well

communicating

hateful

same

ever

however

disparaging

opinion

ordinary

interim

plaintiff

hence

comply

line

there

vulgar

disparage

sought

audience

noted

through

interest

no

said

in the world

two

copy

late

again

felix arvid ulf kjellberg

out

track

off

all in

And

Other

Defendant

Www Youtube Com

Offensive

Repeated

That

Remove

Posting

Not

Rules

Where

Planning

World Of

The

From

Points

My Opinion

Its

Every

4 To 6

Has Been

World Market

Weeks

Sibal

I E

Rules 1 And 2

These

Start

Speed Post

The Platform

Adv

In My

Convenience

Was

With

Let

Rule

In A

Are

Have

Bid

High Court

Had

Do Not

Also

Diss Track

Any More

Https

Available

Www Youtube

Which

Permanent

Global

Process

Throughout

Version

Videos Of

Prima Facie

Has

Accessible

Counsel

Most

Against

In My Opinion

Position

Within

Popularity

Than

Given

Stating

Subject

Some

Seeking

Above

It Was

Earlier

Regain

The Same

A New

A Party

All In Good Fun

And Also

Any

Bitch Lasagna

Dated

Day 4

Exceptions

For The

Have A

I Is

In The

Inflammatory

Is Not

It Is

May Be

Notice

Popularity Of

Prima

Abusive

Accompanying

Across

Ad Interim

Ulf Kjellberg

Amit

Any Other

Abhay

Kaushik

Kjellberg

Nath

Perusal

Varun

As Well As

Assured

Comply With

Decree

Defamatory

Directed

Disable

Favour

For Quite Some Time

In Conjunction

In Conjunction With

In Nature

Increased

More Than

Namely

No 1

On The Face Of It

Outscore

Plaint

Presently

Quite Some Time

Recently

Registered

Returnable

Shows

Significantly

Subject To

Summons

The Most

The Other

found ON 2019-04-11 16:42:35 BY awwmemes.com

source: reddit